Tomato Feta Baked Eggs

There's something about the sizzle of tomatoes hitting hot oil that makes you want to gather everyone into the kitchen at once. A friend brought this sheet pan of baked eggs to brunch last summer, and I watched the whole table light up when it came out of the oven—no fancy plating, just a single pan passed around with crusty bread and everyone reaching in at the same time. That's when I knew this was the kind of recipe that breaks down the distance between cooking and sharing, between effort and reward.

I made this on a Tuesday morning when my sister texted asking if I could do something special for her visit, and I realized I had exactly these ingredients sitting in my fridge. Pulling that pan out ten minutes later, watching the eggs wobble slightly and the tomatoes glistening with their own juice, I felt that small pride that comes from knowing your pantry and trusting it.

Ingredients

• Grape tomatoes, halved (2 cups): The sweetness matters here—cherry tomatoes work too, but grape tomatoes collapse into a jammy texture that coats every bite.
• Garlic, minced (2 cloves): Roasting mellows it completely, so don't shy away from mincing it fine and letting the heat do the work.
• Red onion, thinly sliced (1 small, optional): I skip this sometimes and add it others, depending on whether I want that sharp bite or prefer to let the tomatoes be the story.
• Feta cheese, crumbled (6 oz): Buy it in bulk if you can and crumble it yourself—pre-crumbled tends to clump, and you want pockets of salty cream throughout.
• Large eggs (8): Room temperature eggs cook more evenly, though I've never been patient enough to wait and they still turn out fine.
• Extra-virgin olive oil (2 tbsp): This is where quality shows; use something you actually enjoy tasting on its own.
• Dried oregano (1/2 tsp): One of those herbs that tastes better dried than fresh in this particular application—the concentrated earthiness anchors everything.
• Crushed red pepper flakes (1/4 tsp, optional): I always use these, but adjust based on who's eating; the heat rounds out the richness of the yolk.
• Fresh basil (1/3 cup, torn): Add this only after baking—heat turns fresh basil bitter, and you want that bright green pop at the very end.
• Salt and black pepper: Taste as you layer; the feta is salty, so you're really just balancing the tomatoes.

Instructions

Get your pan ready and preheat:

Line a sheet pan with parchment or a light brush of oil—this matters because feta can stick, and you want to slide the whole thing onto a serving plate if you're feeling fancy. Crank your oven to 400°F and let it come all the way up while you prep; a properly preheated oven is the only reason this happens so fast.

Build your tomato base:

Scatter halved tomatoes across the pan with minced garlic and thin red onion slices if you're using them. Drizzle everything with olive oil, then rain down oregano, red pepper flakes, salt, and pepper—toss it all together with your hands or a spoon until the tomatoes glisten and smell incredible. This first roast is crucial; it starts the sweetness development before the eggs even arrive.

Let tomatoes soften:

Slide the pan into the oven for ten minutes and listen for that subtle sizzle. The tomatoes should just begin to collapse at the edges but still hold their shape; you're not cooking them through, just waking them up.

Crack eggs into wells:

Pull the hot pan out carefully—it's hotter than it looks. Using your fingers or a spoon handle, nudge the tomatoes to create eight small pockets, then crack an egg directly into each space. The residual heat won't cook them, so work quickly and confidently.

Crown with feta and return:

Scatter crumbled feta all over the surface, letting some fall into the crevices and some rest on the tomatoes. Back into the oven for eight to ten minutes—start checking at eight; you want the egg whites just set but the yolks still moving slightly when you jiggle the pan.

Finish with basil and serve:

The moment those eggs are done, pull the pan out and scatter torn fresh basil over everything while it's still steaming. Serve it straight from the pan with bread for scooping and let people help themselves.

Pin It

My brother came home from college hungry and impatient, and this pan came out of the oven just as he walked through the door. He stood in the kitchen eating it directly off the sheet with a fork, not moving, and didn't say anything until it was half gone. That silence told me everything about how a simple combination of roasted tomatoes, creamy eggs, and salty cheese can feel like comfort and celebration at the same time.

Building Flavor in Layers

This dish works because nothing dominates—the tomatoes sweeten and concentrate, the feta brings salt and creaminess, the eggs are tender and rich, and the basil arrives last to keep it all bright. It's a lesson in restraint and timing; you're not adding much, just roasting tomatoes first, then eggs, then basil, letting each step do its job without interference. The space between ingredients matters as much as the ingredients themselves.

Make It Your Own

This is one of those recipes that actually wants you to improvise once you understand the basic structure. Baby spinach wilts into the tomatoes beautifully if you layer it in before cracking the eggs. Roasted red peppers add depth, sliced scallions bring sharpness, and leftover breakfast potatoes tucked underneath make it more substantial when you're feeding hungry people. The beautiful part is that you can't really break it—as long as you respect the timing on the eggs and finish with fresh basil, you're golden.

Serving and Storage Notes

Serve this the moment it comes out of the oven, ideally with crusty sourdough or warm pita for scooping. The leftovers reheat okay but never taste quite as good—the eggs firm up and the tomatoes lose their just-right texture—so really plan to make it for people ready to eat right then. A spoonful of pesto or another drizzle of good olive oil just before serving adds richness if you want it to feel even more special.

• Toast your bread while the eggs cook so everything arrives at the table warm and ready.
• Use room-temperature eggs if you remember, but honestly, cold eggs work fine and no one will know the difference.
• Make this for a crowd—it scales easily and everyone loves passing the same pan around.

Pin It

This is the kind of recipe that lives in that sweet spot between effort and impact, the one you keep making because it works every single time and everyone always asks for it. Make it once and you'll understand why.

Your Questions Answered

→ What type of tomatoes work best for this dish?

Juicy grape or cherry tomatoes are ideal as they soften quickly and add a natural sweetness when roasted.

→ How can I ensure the eggs are cooked perfectly?

After roasting the tomatoes briefly, crack the eggs into wells and bake until the whites are set but yolks remain slightly runny, usually 8–10 minutes.

→ Can I customize the herbs and seasoning?

Absolutely! Oregano and basil provide a Mediterranean touch, but feel free to add or substitute herbs like thyme or parsley to suit your taste.

→ Is it possible to make this dish dairy-free?

Yes, you can omit the feta or replace it with a dairy-free cheese alternative to retain the creamy texture.

→ What serving suggestions pair well with this dish?

Serve hot from the pan with toasted sourdough, pita bread, or alongside sautéed greens for a complete meal.